As a company that specializes in exterior doors and replacement windows for older and historic homes, we find that some of our customers prefer genuine wood instead of some of the maintenance-free alternatives like vinyl or fiberglass. But many Twin Cities homeowners have avoided wood windows and doors because they believe wood is not a good option. Or else they find the varieties of wood available a little mystifying and because of that they skip over wood.
Recently we got a newsletter from our friends at Marvin, one of our favorite window and door manufacturers to work with. The following is from that newsletter, and it’s got some great information on wood windows and doors.
You might think you know wood – but do you know wood for windows and doors? The same properties that make certain woods ideal for other construction projects might make them a complicated choice for window and door components.
This is why wood scientists exist, and why Marvin relies on in-house, advanced-degree holding wood scientists to inform their research and manufacturing processes. If you’re considering wood, you’ll want to know why Marvin’s wood scientist Ben Wallace thinks pine is extremely underrated, oak is a bit high maintenance, and why you shouldn’t just take a supplier’s word for it when they say they’re selling you Honduran mahogany.
Wallace shared five things you probably don’t know about wood and windows.
1. Pine isn’t just less expensive, it’s actually an ideal window material.
According to Wallace, pine might be one of the most underrated choices for wood windows. It’s inexpensive, and though it might not be ideal for flooring, it has exactly the properties a window or door product needs.
“You don’t buy pine flooring because it’s not an ideal choice; it dents and dings too easily,” says Wallace. “But, you won’t be walking on a window. You need it to not shrink or swell too much and for it to be structurally strong but not overly rigid. Pine exhibits all of the best characteristics, and it takes paint and stain incredibly well.”
2. Choosing wood for a window isn’t just about strength.
Certain wood species might be stronger than another, but Wallace insists strength isn’t what’s important about designing a durable window or door, it’s about working with a manufacturer who understands the “personalities” of different types of wood.
“Materials attributes are important, but if you really understand a material, you learn to design for its limitations, accept those and work within them,” says Wallace. “A bad window design with Douglas fir, even though it might be one of the strongest woods out there, will not last as long as a good design with pine.”
3. Not all expensive window and door woods are rare; they might just be difficult to work with.
Speaking of woods with personality, how easy or hard it is to design for various wood species can factor in to how expensive they are. Wallace notes that premium wood pricing is a combination of availability, perception and ease of use. Honduran mahogany isn’t easy to get, hence the premium pricing. White oak, on the other hand, isn’t expensive because it’s difficult to obtain but because it’s more difficult to design for.
“Oak is a hard wood, it shrinks and swells more than other species, and it’s more difficult to dry. It requires more handling and more specialized design, so there’s cost that comes with using it in a window or door,” says Wallace. “It’s popular from an aesthetic standpoint, so we use our wood expertise to prepare it to perform well in a different application.”
4. Honduran mahogany is a term some manufacturers use loosely. The real thing is worth the price, and it’s not easy to get.
Though the term is often used, not all mahogany is created equal. True Honduran mahogany is the Honduran Swietenia Macrophylla species, which must be responsibly sourced from managed forests and is the only type of mahogany that will exhibit the desirable characteristics that make this wood so special.
“All of the Honduran Mahogany we <Marvin> buy is Forestry Steward Council certified. We know exactly where it’s coming from so we can ensure we are enhancing forestation and helping this species thrive,” says Wallace. “It’s harder to obtain, but well worth it.”
5. When it comes to preserving wood, it’s all about exposed surfaces.
As with any organic material, wood needs to be treated to resist rot and pests, and some processes leave untreated areas that could become weak points. Asking about the treatment process can go a long way in protecting your investment in windows and doors.
“(Marvin) uses submersion treatment to get a high loading of not just one, but three active and targeted fungicides, plus an insecticide and water repellant. If any wood component is cut after treatment, we re-submerge to ensure all surface areas are covered, which is where it is needed most,” says Wallace.
If you’d like to re-consider wood windows and doors for your home here in the Minneapolis area, we’d love to talk to you about the options we have available from Marvin. We install Marvin’s genuine wood windows and doors (available in a variety of woods) with aluminum cladding to protect the exteriors from our harsh weather, as well as their Integrity fiberglass windows and doors that have a wood interior option. Contact us today for a free consultation in your home – no obligation.
Window Outfitters, Inc. is a Marvin Authorized Replacement Contractor for the Twin Cities area.